DINE’s Definitive Pie Ranking – Part 2: Savoury

Chile Relleno Pot Pie @spabettie e1552595801488
Chile Relleno Pot Pie @spabettie e1552595801488
Reading Time: 2 minutes

Every March 14th, we don’t only celebrate Albert Einstein’s birthday (would be 140 today), but basically anything filled into flaky, buttery pastry – sweet and savoury alike. It’s International Pi(e) Day! It is also the annual resurgence of the debate: Which is the best pie? We polled our DINE staff and got the definitive ranking here for you. Part 2: Savoury Pies.

7 – Fish Pie

This is not a DINE favourite. Every single staffer ranked this pie at the bottom. First of all, not really a pie. It is a fish stew, cooked in milk and cream and almost always topped with mashed potatoes.

Fish Pie
Credit: @olivemagazine

6 – Steak and Kidney Pie

A few years ago we wouldn’t even have put this as an option on the list. But the resurgence of offal and other off-cuts have this pie gaining popularity and climbing the ranks. At DINE it still has some room to grow.

Steak and Kidney Pie

5 – Tourtière

Canadian pie pride! Hailing from Quebec it is usually made with minced beef, pork, and veal, and further enhanced with wild game like venison or boar.

Credit: @cookscountry

4 – Curried Vegetable (and/or animal protein of choice)

Popularized in Great Britain because of the British passion for Indian food, this pie is a great option for vegetarians and everybody looking for some spice in their pie.

chicken curry pie
Credit: @ittybittypie

3 – Shepherd’s Pie

Many quibbled if this should be listed, since technically it is only called a pie – no pastry. Technically, shmechnically, we say… DINE staff will eat anything topped with a mountain of mashed potatoes – except fish pie apparently.

Shepherd's Pie
Credit: @cookscountry

2 – Chicken Pot Pie/Chicken and Mushroom Pie

Surely, the most popular of savoury pies. Contrary to its popularity, we think this pie is still underrated. Maybe it’s too many bad experiences with chicken pot pies straight out of the  frozen aisle at the supermarket. Make one yourself and let the comfort wash over you.

Chicken Pot Pie
Credit: @in_dfwfamily

1 – Steak and Ale Pie

We have a winner, ladies and gentlemen. Beef, beer, and pastry, what’s not to love? Rich dark gravy, mushrooms, the odd vegetable… sorry we’re getting carried away. Top marks: #1.

Steak and Ale Pie
Credit: @bbcfood

Read more: 

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Written by Kevin Sachs

Kevin Sachs was born and raised in Zurich, Switzerland. As a former broadcast journalist for SRF, his previous works were featured in Haaretz, Le Matin, Tagesanzeiger, Süddeutsche Zeitung and AWE Magazine. With his passion for all things food and travel, it was only a matter of time until he ended up at DINE Magazine.


DINE’s Definitive Pie Ranking – Part 1: Sweet

large pizza

You Can Now Order Canada’s Biggest Pizza in Toronto!